HOA Governing Documents Explained: CC&Rs, Bylaws, and Rules (and What Each Controls)
Most homeowners — and many board members — can't explain the difference between CC&Rs, bylaws, and rules. Here's what each document actually controls and why it matters for governance.
Every HOA operates under a stack of governing documents — and understanding which document controls what is fundamental to running a board correctly. Make a rule that conflicts with the CC&Rs, and the rule loses. Try to amend the bylaws with a simple board vote, and the amendment is void. Reference "our policies" in meeting minutes without knowing which document you're operating under, and you've created ambiguity that can undermine enforcement.
Here's a plain-English guide to how the documents work and what each one controls.
The Document Hierarchy
HOA governing documents exist in a hierarchy. When documents conflict, the higher-level document wins. From highest to lowest authority:
- State law — supersedes everything; HOA documents cannot override state statutes
- Recorded declaration (CC&Rs or Declaration of Covenants)
- Articles of Incorporation (if the HOA is a corporation, which most are)
- Bylaws
- Rules and Regulations (adopted by the board)
- Board resolutions — policies adopted for specific situations
When you're trying to figure out what authority the board has for a particular action, you work up this hierarchy until you find the governing provision.
The CC&Rs (Declaration of Covenants, Conditions & Restrictions)
What they are
CC&Rs are recorded in the county property records and run with the land — meaning they bind every owner of every lot in the community, now and in the future, automatically upon purchase. They're essentially a contract between every homeowner and the association that attaches to the property itself.
What they control
- The nature and purpose of the community
- What owners can and can't do with their property (use restrictions)
- Assessment authority — how assessments can be levied and what they fund
- Common area ownership and maintenance obligations
- Enforcement authority and remedies
- Insurance requirements
- Major dispute resolution procedures
How they're amended
CC&Rs require owner approval — typically a supermajority of all owners (commonly 67-75%), not just those who vote. Amendment requires a formal vote, usually at a noticed member meeting, and the amendment must be recorded with the county recorder to take effect. This is intentionally difficult — these are the foundational rules of the community.
What board members need to know
The board cannot override CC&Rs. If the CC&Rs say the board can levy assessments up to $X per unit per year, the board cannot levy more regardless of need. If the CC&Rs restrict certain uses, the board cannot waive those restrictions — only owners can, through the amendment process.
The Bylaws
What they are
Bylaws govern the internal operations of the association as an organization — how the board is structured, how elections work, how meetings are conducted, what officers do. They're not recorded in property records (unlike CC&Rs) but are legally binding on the association and its members.
What they control
- Board composition, terms, and qualifications
- Officer roles and responsibilities
- Meeting requirements — frequency, notice, quorum
- Election procedures
- Voting rights
- Amendment procedures for the bylaws themselves
- Committee authority
How they're amended
Bylaw amendments typically require owner approval but at a lower threshold than CC&Rs — commonly a majority or two-thirds of owners voting at a properly noticed meeting. Some associations allow the board to adopt minor bylaw amendments; others require member votes for all changes. Check your bylaws for the amendment procedure.
What board members need to know
Bylaws define the board's authority and procedures. When the board wants to do something — create a new committee, change the meeting schedule, adjust how the secretary handles records — the bylaws either authorize it or they don't. Board decisions that exceed bylaw authority are challengeable.
Rules and Regulations
What they are
Rules and regulations (sometimes called "community rules" or "house rules") are adopted by the board and can generally be changed by the board without owner approval. They fill in the operational details that the CC&Rs and bylaws don't address — parking rules, pool hours, pet policies, move-in/move-out procedures, noise standards.
What they control
- Day-to-day community behavior standards
- Use of common amenities (pool, gym, clubhouse)
- Parking and vehicle restrictions
- Pet policies
- Rental restrictions (to the extent the CC&Rs don't address them)
- Enforcement fine schedules
How they're amended
The board can typically adopt, amend, or repeal rules by board vote — no owner approval required. However, rules cannot contradict CC&Rs or bylaws. And in California and some other states, homeowners must be given advance notice of proposed rule changes and an opportunity to comment before adoption.
What board members need to know
Rules are your most flexible tool — you can update them to address new situations. But they must stay within the authority the CC&Rs grant the board, and they must be enforced consistently. An unenforced rule is a liability; a selectively enforced rule is a bigger one.
Board Resolutions
Resolutions are formal board decisions on specific operational matters — approving a specific contract, establishing a committee, adopting a collection policy, setting an assessment. They're not a separate document layer but rather the mechanism by which the board exercises its authority under the bylaws and rules.
Resolutions should be documented in meeting minutes. "The board moved and approved…" is essentially a resolution in narrative form.
Common Conflicts and How to Resolve Them
"Our rules say X but the CC&Rs say Y."
The CC&Rs win. The board cannot enforce a rule that contradicts the CC&Rs, even if it was properly adopted. The rule is void to the extent of the conflict.
"The board adopted a no-pet policy but the CC&Rs allow pets."
The board cannot restrict what the CC&Rs expressly permit. A board-adopted pet ban in a community whose CC&Rs allow pets is unenforceable without a CC&R amendment.
"The bylaws say we need 4 board members for quorum but we only have 3."
You don't have quorum. The bylaws control. No business can be transacted. The solution is to fill the vacant seat or amend the bylaws — not to declare a quorum anyway.
What This Means for Meeting Minutes
When your minutes reference a governing document, be specific about which one. "Per our rules" is less useful than "Per Section 5.3 of the Rules and Regulations." Specificity makes it easier to verify the authority, enforce the decision, and defend it if challenged.
When the board takes action based on a specific document provision, cite it: "Pursuant to Article VIII, Section 2 of the Bylaws…" This creates a clean paper trail that links board decisions to their authorizing authority.
How MinuteSmith Helps
Board meetings regularly involve references to governing documents — "per the CC&Rs," "under Section X of the Bylaws," "per the Rules." MinuteSmith captures these references as spoken, so the minutes reflect the actual authority cited rather than a paraphrase. The result is minutes that are more useful as governance records and more defensible when challenged.
Try MinuteSmith free — no credit card required for your first meeting.